Customer story · AI-Enabled Takeoff & Estimating Service

Fully Quantified Estimate, VE Log, and Risk Register at 100% SD — Delivered in a Fraction of the Time Local Estimators Could Match

When the design team was still working through assumptions and local estimators were returning vague trade buckets, MeltPlan produced a line-item estimate across 20 CSI divisions, a VE log that cut costs without touching the design intent, and a risk register the whole team could use going into the next phase.

Jacob Gorman, Construction Project Manager, Mindsai Gardens
Jacob Gorman
Construction Project Manager
Mindsai Gardens
4x
Faster estimate turnaround
than local estimators
16
Drawing sheets fully quantified,
every item tagged to manufacturer,
color & dimension
$9.7M
Total construction cost
estimated
17,072
SF project lot area,
Cardiff-by-the-Sea, CA
Value Engineering Log delivered
Risk Register with major cost & schedule risks
Scope gap identification at 100% SD stage

Ground-up restaurant in San Diego, aggressive budget, design team still working through assumptions at 100% SDs. MeltPlan filled the gaps where drawings weren’t telling the full story and got the design team to validate what needed validating. The VE log was the standout — prefab options, a smart day one vs. day two split, real savings without touching the look and feel. Risk register gave the client actual predictability on major cost and schedule risks. Good mix of experienced people and AI doing the heavy lifting on numbers.

Jacob Gorman
Construction Project Manager
Mindsai Gardens
About the project

A coastal North County San Diego food hall designed as a community third place

Among Mindsai Gardens’ active development projects is a ground-up mixed-use food hall concept on a 17,072 SF coastal parcel at 1967 San Elijo Avenue in Cardiff-by-the-Sea, California. The concept: nine modular food stalls on an elevated two-story podium, designed to give local vendors unobstructed Pacific views and serve the North County community as a destination gathering space. The project includes an open parking garage, Crow’s Nest observation point, 21-panel solar array, glulam trellis structure, and 4,610 SF of landscaped exterior deck, designed by Stephen Dalton Architects with civil by Latitude 33 and landscape by NLA Landscape Architecture.

Jacob Gorman, a former DPR Construction project executive turned developer, was leading preconstruction. He knew exactly what a defensible estimate looked like. What he was getting from local North County estimators at 100% schematic design wasn’t it — vague by-trade buckets with no quantities, no manufacturer specs, and nothing the design team could act on. When he saw Tanmaya Kala — a DPR colleague turned founder — on LinkedIn, he reached out. The first deliverable answered every question he had about whether MeltPlan could match the standard he’d held his GC teams to.

Featured project
ProjectMindsai Gardens
Location1967 San Elijo Ave
Cardiff-by-the-Sea, CA
Owner1967 San Elijo, LLC
ArchitectStephen Dalton Architects
Estimate basis100% SD Set, 03/10/2026
Total construction cost$9,702,730
Total lot area17,072 SF (0.39 AC)
Occupancy / typeType 5A, A & S, 2 stories
DeliverablesEstimate + VE log
+ Risk register
The challenge

The local estimators couldn’t deliver what the project actually needed

At 100% schematic design for a niche coastal project outside the Bay Area, Jacob needed more than a budget number. He needed a deliverable the whole team could use going into the next phase.

Vague trade buckets, no quantities

“Concrete would cost this much, steel would cost this much.” The local estimator couldn’t tell Jacob what was inside the concrete number — no cubic yardage takeoffs, no footing types, no assumptions documented. For a project with 20 CSI divisions, that isn’t a real estimate.

SD drawings needed gap-filling, not just counting

At 100% SD, the design team was still working through assumptions. The estimator had to identify what wasn’t yet resolved and get the design team to validate it — not just count what existed. Local estimators at this stage weren’t equipped for that kind of collaborative preconstruction work.

No VE log, no risk register, no next-phase tool

The client needed cost cuts that preserved design intent, and a risk register the whole team could use going forward. Neither was something a local estimator’s budget spreadsheet could produce. Jacob had seen what preconstruction looks like at GCs with rigorous preconstruction practices. He wasn’t willing to settle for less.

The solution

A preconstruction team with real GC pedigree, backed by AI that works at project speed

Jacob found Tanmaya Kala through his professional network. He had seen Tanmaya operate as a project executive and knew what that pedigree meant in practice. When he saw MeltPlan on LinkedIn, he reached out — and confirmed the team could take on a project outside the Bay Area.

MeltPlan’s estimating team brought the same construction intelligence Jacob was used to from rigorous preconstruction operations — the ability to read a 100% SD set, identify what isn’t yet resolved, and produce a quantity-driven estimate with every manufacturer, every color, and every size called out from the drawings.

Behind that team sits proprietary AI that handles the volume work at 10x speed: takeoff extraction, quantity verification, unit cost assembly across all 20 CSI divisions and 16 drawing sheets covering architecture, civil, MEP, and landscape. Estimators focus on judgment, QC, the VE opportunities, and the construction intelligence that no model replaces.

The result was a full estimate at 100% SD, a VE log with day one vs. day two splits, and a risk register the client could use entering the design development phase.

AI-accelerated, human-verified

Proprietary AI drives takeoffs and quantity extraction across all 16 drawing sheets. Experienced estimators review every number before delivery.

Full-spectrum deliverable across 20 CSI divisions

Every line item with quantity, unit cost, and extension. Every finish material tagged by manufacturer, color code, and dimension — from Tesselle Triangle Breeze Block to Moz Designs laser-cut railings.

VE log with day one/day two splits

Prefab options, phased scope recommendations, and targeted cuts that preserved design intent and gave the owner real decisions — not just a number to react to.

Risk register for the full team

Major cost and schedule risks identified and documented. The client entered design development with predictability on the items that could move the number most.

Beyond the estimate

The VE log and risk register that set up the next phase

At 100% SD stage with the design still resolving assumptions, the standard estimate wasn’t enough. MeltPlan delivered two additional documents that turned the estimate from a number into a tool the whole team could use going into design development.

Value Engineering Log
Cuts that don’t touch the design intent
Prefab modular container options evaluated vs. site-built food stalls — day one vs. day two scope split identified
Exterior material substitutions flagged for Moz Designs laser-cut panels (MTL-2: $200/SF, 354 SF) — value-matched alternatives surfaced
Conveying systems phasing: elevator E1 ($195K) vs. wheelchair lift ($45K) staged delivery options evaluated
Paving type substitutions on the largest single line item (Paving D: $57.50/SF × 9,137 SF = $525K) reviewed for permeable alternatives
Landscape scope — green roof planting, corten steel planters, ornamental elements — prioritized for phased delivery
Risk Register
Cost & schedule risks documented for the full team
Coastal Cardiff permitting exposure flagged: Cardiff Specific Plan (SP-5) zoning compliance and NFPA 13 sprinkler requirements
Unforeseen subsurface conditions: coastal parcel with 400 CY soil cut and 310 CY export at risk of encountering below-grade conditions
8% escalation to mid-point ($718K) flagged against aggressive target of construction completion before December 2026
Non-competitive bid conditions risk: <3 bids on specialty items (Cookson roll-up gates $45K ea, modular wetland system $23K) could add 10–25% to those line items
SD-stage design assumptions documented: 15% design contingency + 5% estimating contingency built in to reflect current stage uncertainty
Snapshot of the final deliverable

What a MeltPlan estimate actually looks like

Every MeltPlan estimate follows the same rigorous structure: quantities measured from the drawings, composite unit pricing on every line item, a full CSI division breakdown, and documented qualifications and exclusions. The Mindsai Gardens estimate shows the standard at work across a 20-division, 16-sheet project.

Grand summary: full cost roll-up
Total direct trade cost$5,742,195
Design contingency (15%)$861,329
Estimating contingency (5%)$287,110
Total direct cost incl. contingency$6,890,634
General conditions & GR (20%)$1,378,127
Office overhead / GC fee (6%)$496,126
Bond and insurance (2.5%)$219,122
Total cost before escalation$8,984,009
Escalation to mid-point (8%)$718,721
Total construction cost$9,702,730

$568.34/SF of lot area · Basis: 100% SD Set, 03/10/2026

CSI division summary: cost by division
Div 03: Concrete$775,956
Div 04: Masonry$434,176
Div 05: Metals$46,498
Div 06: Wood & plastics$187,111
Div 07: Thermal & moisture$397,639
Div 08: Openings$191,800
Div 09: Finishes$100,415
Div 10: Specialties$306,045
Div 14: Conveying$240,000
Div 21: Fire suppression$350,655
Div 22: Plumbing$218,616
Div 23: HVAC$431,945
Div 26: Electrical$505,953
Div 32: Site improvements$1,172,722
Div 33: Utilities$97,353
Total direct trade cost$5,742,195
Sample detail: Masonry & Specialties
CMU-1 Tesselle Triangle Breeze Block, 7.5", Natural Gray — 1,128 SF@$112.50 = $126,988
CMU-2 RCP Precision Block, Natural Gray — 1,971 SF@$34.75 = $68,506
CMU-3 8"×8" Vertical Stack, Natural Gray — 4,329 SF@$46.20 = $200,000
TL-1 Tilebar Brick, Standoff Pin, Terracotta — 43.66 SF@$68.00 = $2,969
Grout-filled CMU stem wall — 870 SF@$41.05 = $35,714
Div 04 Masonry$434,176
9 corrugated metal food stalls, 40"L × 8'W × 9'H@$15,250 = $137,250
Wall signage, 100 SF (city compliance)$11,250
Crow’s Nest observation point$20,000
Bike rack (8-cap, 5 EA) + repair station$11,000
Bathroom partition walls — 73.81 LF@$1,500 = $110,715
Div 10 Specialties$306,045
Sample detail: Division 32 Site & Landscape
Paving D — 24"×48" pedestrian pavers, 9,137 SF@$57.50 = $525,360
Paving A — non-permeable vehicular (Topcoat #5), 2,808 SF@$35.00 = $98,280
Paving C — permeable pedestrian on permeable base, 1,006 SF@$45.00 = $45,270
Proposed trash enclosure — 331 SF@$195 = $64,594
Garden room — 213 SF@$232.50 = $49,536
Brahea Edulis (Guadalupe Palm) 10’ BTH, 5 EA@$3,650 = $18,250
Southern CA native plantings — 1,365 SF@$17.00 = $23,205
Corten steel planters (4 EA)$24,650
Green roof planting — 126 SF@$60.00 = $7,560
Curb and gutter — 262 LF@$80.00 = $20,985
Div 32 Site improvements$1,172,722
Qualifications & exclusions
Estimate basis100% SD Set, 03/10/2026
Delivery methodDesign-bid-build, lump sum, min. 3 bids
Labor rate basisPrevailing wages, Alameda County
Quantity methodActual measurement; parametric where needed
Unit pricesComposite (material, labor, equipment, sub markups, sales tax)
Contingencies15% design + 5% estimating
Escalation8% to mid-point of construction
Bid conditions1 bid: +25–75% · 2–3: +10–25% · 6–7: 0–(10%)
Named exclusions (13)Design fees, permits, testing, owner admin, change orders, escalation beyond allowance, hazmat beyond allowances
Actual pages from the estimate
Snapshots from the Mindsai Gardens deliverable

Showing the depth and structure of a MeltPlan estimate in practice — every division, every manufacturer spec, every quantity traced to source.

Snapshot of the final deliverable

Every quantity traced back to the drawing

MeltPlan’s takeoff markups show every quantity color-coded to its source: architectural, civil, structural, and landscape drawings all cross-referenced into the final estimate.

The engagement

One fully-proved project. Every deliverable component, executed.

Mindsai Gardens brought MeltPlan into a complex mixed-use project at 100% SD stage — covering architecture, civil, MEP, and landscape across a coastal California parcel with an aggressive timeline and a design team still working through assumptions.

$9.7M
Total construction cost estimated
20
CSI divisions covered
16
Drawing sheets fully quantified
3
Disciplines cross-referenced (Arch, Civil, Landscape)
5
Deliverable components (estimate, VE log, risk register, takeoff markups, qualifications)

Detailed estimates, delivered fast

Developers, GCs, and owners needing rigorous preconstruction on projects of any size. Same team, same rigor, same speed.

Book a Meeting
MELTPLAN